Stacking the Deck for Photons
Adapted from information supplied by the Public Affairs Office at NIST
JQI researchers can speed up photons to seemingly faster-than-light speeds through a stack of materials by adding a single, strategically placed layer. This experimental demonstration confirms intriguing quantum-physics predictions that light's transit time through a material need not depend on a material's thickness, as it does for simple materials such as glass, but rather, in the case of complex multilayered materials, on the order in which the layers are stacked. This is the first published study* of this dependence with single photons.
Strictly speaking, light always achieves its maximum speed in a vacuum, or empty space, and slows down appreciably when it travels through a material substance, such as glass or water. The same is true for light traveling through a stack of dielectric materials, which are electrically insulating and can be used to create highly reflective structures that are often used as optical coatings on mirrors or fiber optics.
In a follow up to earlier experimental measurements, the JQI researchers created stacks of approximately 30 dielectric layers, each about 80 nanometers thick, equivalent to about a quarter of a wavelength of the light traveling through it. The layers alternated between high (H) and low (L) refractive index material, which cause light waves to bend or reflect by varying amounts. After a single photon hits the boundary between the H and L layers, it has a chance of being reflected or passing through.
When encountering a stack of 30 layers alternating between L and H, the rare photons that completely penetrate the stack pass through in about 12.84 femtoseconds (quadrillionths of a second). Adding a single low-index layer to the end of this stack disproportionately increased the photon transit time by 3.52 fs to about 16.36 femtoseconds (fs). (The transit time through this added layer would be only about 0.58 fs, if it depended only upon the layer's thickness and refractive index.) On the contrary, adding an extra H layer to a stack of 30 layers alternating between H and L would reduce the transit time to about 5.34 fs, so that individual photons seem to emerge through the 2.6-micron-thick stack at superluminal (faster-than-light) speeds.
"A key strangeness of quantum mechanics," says JQI Fellow and coauthor Paul Lett, "is that it lets a particle tunnel through a barrier and appear on the other side. Even stranger is that the time it takes to appear on the other side of the barrier can be independent of the thickness. This leads to apparent travel times that can be faster than the speed of light."
What the JQI researchers are seeing can be explained by the wave properties of light. In this experiment, the light begins and ends its existence acting as a particle—a photon. But when one of these photons hits a boundary between the layers of material, it creates waves at each surface, and the traveling light waves interfere with each other just as opposing ocean waves cause a riptide at the beach. With the H and L layers arranged just right, the interfering light waves combine to give rise to transmitted photons that emerge early.
"We model the tunneling effect as one of the few occasions when a single photon manages to survive a crossing of a stack optical coating layers designed to act as highly reflecting mirror," adds JQI Fellow Alan Migdall, also a coauthor. "With this system we demonstrate yet another oddity - the addition of a single coating layer to a stack of many layers can change the photon transit time through the entire stack by many times the ordinary transit time through a single layer, and that change can make the transit time larger or smaller!"
When the time is so short that it appears superluminal, no faster-than-light-speed information transfer actually occurs. The phenomenon is something of an illusion: Only a small proportion of photons make it through the stack, and if all the initial photons were detected, the detectors would record photons over a normal distribution of times.
* See reference publication.